What’s happening in New England’s rural economy?  What’s happening in New England’s rural economy?

Overview Overview

Rural communities make up most of New England, and they play an important role in its economy. They also have unique opportunities and challenges. In this episode of Six Hundred Atlantic, we focus on the demographic and economic trends shaping rural New England, from population shifts and workforce shortages to housing affordability and childcare and healthcare access.

We also explore why regional rural communities have higher incomes and lower poverty rates than their counterparts across the country, and what current demographics mean for rural New England’s future.

Visit bostonfed.org to read the full paper, “New England’s Rural Economy: An Overview." For more interviews and analysis of the economy in New England and nationwide, visit bostonfed.org/sixhundredatlantic.aspx. Subscribe to our email list to stay updated on new episodes.

Transcript Transcript

Allison Ross:

The Federal Reserve Bank of Boston might be located in the city, but it serves nearly all of New England, from its largest cities to its smallest towns. In fact, about two thirds of New England's land area falls within counties classified as rural. So, it's a crucial part of the economy.

Are rural areas thriving or struggling? How are they faring compared to the rest of the country? And how are challenges such as an aging workforce, childcare, and limited access to healthcare and housing impacting the future?

I'm your host, Allison Ross, and this is Six Hundred Atlantic, a podcast produced by the Boston Fed. Joining me is Jeff Thompson, a Boston Fed vice president and economist and director of the New England Public Policy Center. His latest research is titled, “New England's Rural Economy: An Overview”. It takes a closer look at rural areas, from population shifts to employment and income levels.

And it examines what those findings tell us about the communities that make up so much of our region.

Welcome back to the podcast, Jeff.

Jeff Thompson:

Thanks for having me.

Allison Ross:

Let's start with a definition. How do we define an area as rural versus urban?

Jeff Thompson:

So, there are a couple of different approaches to this, but we follow the approach used by researchers at the USDA, the U.S. Department of Agriculture, and they essentially define all rural communities as being those that are not in a metropolitan area. So metropolitan areas are going to be the big cities and the suburbs that surround them, and those communities are defined by economic linkages, commuting flows, et cetera. So, if you're not in a metropolitan area, you're in a rural community. And it's an interesting definition because sometimes you might find yourself in a place that feels rural. There are farms and there are lots of trees, but because of its proximity to the metropolitan core, you're still going to be not counted as rural.

Allison Ross:

So how much of New England's population does live in these rural areas and where are those communities concentrated?

Jeff Thompson:

We have about 12% of New Englanders live in rural counties and other than Rhode Island, they do include all the New England states. So, you see a couple of the planning regions in Connecticut are identified as rural. You have three counties in Massachusetts that are considered rural, but most of New England's rural areas are in the northern tier, so Maine, New Hampshire and Vermont.

Allison Ross:

We often hear about young people moving out of smaller communities to more urban areas to start their jobs, maybe pursue a career. To what degree is that happening here in New England?

Jeff Thompson:

That's definitely happening in New England as well as in other parts of the country. Historically, especially, we've seen the fastest rates of job growth in the urban areas. And so that dynamic is present in New England to be sure.

And one of the things that we see when we look at the data by age, we do see just declining numbers of young people. And so, we did a report a couple of years ago and identified that in the first two decades of this century, so from about 2000 to late 2010s, all 40 of the counties in the northern tier states saw declining population between the five to 19 age bin. So that's the school age range. But those are the feeders. The 19-year-old is going to become the 20-year-old looking for work.

And what we see is just declining numbers of those people. And so partly some of the reasons for the declining numbers of people, young school-age people, is that the families with children are oftentimes relocating. They're relocating to urban areas, young professionals relocating to urban areas, and that's where they end up taking their families.

Allison Ross:

And we know that New England is the oldest region in the country, but we also know many of its states are among the lowest in fertility. Is that also a problem that you're seeing in rural areas? Are they seeing any impact because not enough babies are being born?

Jeff Thompson:

That is a factor that shapes a lot of rural New England. Definitely New England is among the oldest regions, and particularly the three northern states, which house most of the region's rural communities. So, the national average dependency ratio, which is just the measure of the number of adults 65 and older to the 18 to 64 population, and nationally that's about 30%, but in Maine it's closer to 38%. In New Hampshire and Vermont, it's closer to 36%. So that clearly shapes those regions, and it means that there's of the people there, maybe there are greater needs, but there's also just fewer people to meet the needs of the older population that happens to live there.

And on the younger side of the age spectrum, we do just see declining numbers of young people. We saw that, and that's been true for decades, really. And there are consequences of that that shape those communities. So, for example, in some work we did a couple of years ago looking at the closure and the consolidation of school districts, there are a lot of communities where the school-age population has shrunk, and as a result, they've struggled to keep schools open.

Allison Ross:

I also hear about declining marriage rates. Is this part of the story too?

Jeff Thompson:

It absolutely is. I do have to say that for this report, we didn't dig into that specific data, but from other work, we do know that across the board we're seeing delayed marriages and lower rates of marriage, and that's happening in urban communities and in rural communities. And so, when you have delayed and less marriage, it's associated with having fewer children and having children later, and so that ultimately feeds into the slower population dynamics that we're seeing, and we're seeing them in urban communities and definitely in rural communities as well.

Allison Ross:

Okay. Thanks for that.

I want to talk about a few things in your brief that I found surprising. First, you found that rural counties in New England are far better off in terms of income and poverty rates than the rest of the country. Why is that?

Jeff Thompson:

There are two main reasons why we see counties, rural counties in New England being more prosperous, higher incomes, lower poverty. And the primary factor is really about education. So, New England as a whole is more highly educated than the rest of the country, and that's also true in its rural communities. And so, with higher levels of education, New England's rural residents are able to get more highly paid occupations. So that's one of the payoffs to education.

There is another factor which has to do with New England being a fairly small and compact region. So, a lot of the communities that are identified as rural in New England are still fairly close into the orbit of the urban areas. And so, they're still able to potentially access the economies of those places. They're less remote. So even within New England, if we look further afield and we look at the most isolated parts of rural New England, so the very northern tiers of New Hampshire and much of northern Maine, those communities have lower incomes and higher poverty.

Allison Ross:

Okay. So, proximity.

Why is it that unemployment is lower in rural than urban areas, despite the fact that it has had similar employment growth over the past couple of years?

Jeff Thompson:

Yeah. This is a really interesting dynamic, and I should note that it's in fact quite different from the pattern that we see at the national level. So, at the national level, we see lower employment growth, but unemployment is on par. We see a very different story in New England. If you sort of pull it apart and in your mind, you paint a picture of what a rural community might be like. And you might think on the job side, maybe with less population and less industry, less activity, there's going to be fewer jobs. And there are some of those out there.

But you always have to remember that there's the other side of the equation with unemployment, which is population. And so rural places are also going to have less population growth and fewer people. And you can have low unemployment if you just have relatively few people to access the jobs, even if there are fairly few jobs.

And also, recently in the last few years in New England, it's the urban communities that have seen slower job growth. Like Massachusetts, mostly urban, has really slowed down.

And so, the rural communities in New England haven't slowed down as much. It's really like they've sort of leveled up. So, if you looked at a long-time horizon, you're going to see much, much slower job growth in New England's rural communities,.

Allison Ross:

Do we know why it slowed in Massachusetts?

Jeff Thompson:

That is a complicated story. So, in the previous expansion, there were a few sectors that were really powerful and really outperformed the rest of the region and the country. And those are the high-tech sector, hospitals, and construction. Those were the three dominant forces driving job growth the last time around. And since 2022, all three of those have really fallen flat and they're kind of interrelated. A lot of the job growth in the construction sector was building labs, and lab growth has really just fallen off. The tech sector has slowed down, but also AI building happening everywhere else in the country has absorbed a huge amount of the funding for building labs. So that's been taken away.

And we're also the subject of some of the changes in policy at the national level in terms of funding for research, things like the NIH.

Allison Ross:

Got it. Thanks for that.

Now, New England has a large ocean economy. What kind of jobs are included in an ocean economy and what role does it play in the larger regional economy as a whole?

Jeff Thompson:

So, fisheries, hatcheries, the fleets of ships that are bringing in lobsters and the shellfish farmers, those are all ocean economy jobs, but so are boat builders, so is marine transportation, so are the dock warehouses that house and store the catch before it gets sent off. But it also goes more broad than that. You're going to have a lot of tourism. In fact, tourism that happens in and near the water is going to be the single largest category, so tourism and recreation.

Allison Ross:

Can we talk about the interaction between the rural economy and the ocean economy?

Jeff Thompson:

Yeah. Interestingly, a lot of, and I was surprised to find this, a lot of the ocean economy is in fact in the urban communities. But for a lot of parts of New England in the rural communities, ocean economy is quite important, and we really see that coming out in Maine. In Maine, ocean economy jobs account for nearly 6% of total employment. Nationally, that's only 1.2%. Ocean economy jobs are just 1.2% of national rural county employment. So, it's particularly important in Maine. And when you dig in and see what jobs exactly are we talking about? We're talking about fishing, marinas, hatcheries, we're talking about boat building. There's a lot of tourism and recreation as well. That does remain the largest class of ocean economy jobs, but there's just a wide variety.

Marine transportation provides a nontrivial portion of the ocean economy jobs in rural Maine. So, for rural Maine in particular, it's really quite important. And in Massachusetts, what you see is the rural counties affected by the ocean economy are the islands. So, the Cape and Islands. The Cape is actually urban, but it's the islands that are rural, and out there, ocean economy is really quite important. Mostly tourism and recreation, but fishing and living resources are also important out there.

Allison Ross:

And so, by islands, you mean Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard, those are considered rural?

Jeff Thompson:

Yeah. It is interesting that in Massachusetts, those are two rural communities, and it's essentially just driven by the definition that we talked about at the very beginning. So, they're not in a metropolitan area and they're not in the direct economic orbit of the metropolitan area. So, they are rural and they do look different from many of the other rural communities across New England. It's one of the reasons we talked a little bit earlier about low poverty and high income in New England's rural communities and the fact that Martha's Vineyard and Nantucket are rural communities in New England is part of that story.

Allison Ross:

Our Bank President Susan Collins recently talked publicly about some of the challenges in rural areas such as labor shortages and limited access to childcare and healthcare services.

What are you seeing in these areas, and do these issues feed into each other?

Jeff Thompson:

I think they do feed into each other, and those issues are very much alive and present across rural New England. So, let's just take childcare.

We had some recent work come out looking at childcare, the impacts of access to and the cost of childcare and how that affects the labor market prospects of mothers of young children. And so, in doing that work, the authors mapped out the entire New England region, and they identified places that have either relatively low supply of childcare slots and high, and then also cost, low-cost and high cost. So, if you look across most of rural New England, you're going to see lots of areas that have low supply, but they also have low cost. So, there are a lot of communities where childcare is very affordable, just hard to get.

Allison Ross:

What about healthcare as a challenge too?

Jeff Thompson:

Healthcare does remain a distinct challenge for rural New England. In previous work that the policy center has done, we've tracked the closure of nursing home facilities and nursing home beds across the region. We've also tracked closures of healthcare facilities and maternity wards, and all of these types of facilities have seen a larger decline in rural communities. So, there are now more rural communities across New England and more rural New Englanders without easy access to maternity-care wards. It remains an issue. We still see pressures on the healthcare sector. It's pressing for those communities and it's not getting any easier.

Allison Ross:

I want to talk specifically about housing. People used to look to rural places to find more affordable housing, but it's not as much of a refuge anymore. So, what are you seeing and what makes a rural housing squeeze different?

Jeff Thompson:

Yeah, we've explored this issue as well in separate work. And to some extent, the housing sort of safety net valve, if you will, has kind of always been a mirage with respect to the current residents of rural communities. Because if you look at rent price-to-income ratios, or house price-to-income ratios, they've always been fairly similar. So, it's really that people living in urban communities in New England and elsewhere have always viewed the rural communities as being relatively attractive because they have their urban income, and they think with my urban income, I could go move to that rural place and buy a lot of house.

But the picture has changed for housing affordability in rural communities, and some of that has to do with COVID. In COVID, everyone remembers the world shut down, and in New England, a lot of people ended up leaving Boston and sort of temporarily relocating to northern parts of the region, and many of those are rural communities. And so, what you did see in recent years is an influx of population. A lot of people are going to Maine. So, Maine has actually seen very favorable population developments, but that has meant an influx of buyers.

And so, you've seen housing affordability even for the urban dwellers sort of looking longingly at the housing prices in the regions of rural communities, they're seeing those prices now are rising. So, it's exacerbating housing affordability considerably in the rural communities.

Allison Ross:

I was living in Maine at the time. I do remember the influx of people coming.

In New England, like the rest of the country, most of the land is classified as rural, but most people don't live there. Does that dynamic have any impacts? Do you think the needs in rural areas get overlooked because most people aren't living there, even though land-wise New England is mostly rural?

Jeff Thompson:

I would say yes to both parts of that question.

The fact that a lot of rural communities are distanced from the bulk of economic activity can take them off the table as to viable expansion opportunities. So, we just talked about housing issues. Well, maybe a solution for people confronting high housing costs in the urban areas is to go out to the rural communities. And so, the question is, if they did that, what would be there for them? So, you can escape, potentially escape high housing costs, but you move to an area where there is no job availability.

On the firm side, maybe you as a firm could go ahead and establish your new operation or a satellite facility in a rural community. Okay, if you did that, would you have access to workforce?

And the second issue that you raised is are rural communities, do they not get the attention that they need?

This is a tough question, right. Because I'm sure that many of the residents in rural communities feel that they don't receive the attention. In fact, I've witnessed it myself. I travel around the region as well, sometimes giving presentations in rural communities, and you do hear that. But if you measure it on a per capita basis, I'm not sure that that actually holds. I mean, a lot of the ways that the regional governments, the state governments in the region allocate funding is on a per capita basis. And so, to the extent that there's, say, less funding is really tied to low population.

Allison Ross:

Got it. Thanks for that.

Now, an important question I think is, why is understanding rural economies important to the Boston Fed's work and how can research like this inform decisions in our region?

Jeff Thompson:

We're called Boston Fed, but we serve the whole region. And the First District includes all of New England except for one county in Connecticut. So, we serve the whole region, so it's important for us to know what's going on everywhere. And even though the population of rural counties is, as we mentioned, only 12% of the region, that's still 12%, and some of those sectors are quite important. So, the ocean economy, some of those exports are some of the things that make New England world-famous, our lobsters, the rugged coastline of Maine.

So, the far-flung parts of New England, whether technically rural or just seeming rural, make huge contributions and are part of what gives our region its character. And, everybody counts.

Allison Ross:

Jeff, thank you so much and thanks for joining us on the podcast.

Jeff Thompson:

Thanks for having me.

Allison Ross:

Jeff's paper is titled, “New England's Rural Economy: An Overview”. Check out bostonfed.org/six-hundred-Atlantic where you can find a link to the paper and listen to interviews as well as our podcast seasons. You can also subscribe to our email list to stay up to date on new episodes and don't forget to rate, review, share, and subscribe to Six Hundred Atlantic on your favorite podcast app.

I'm Allison Ross signing off for another episode of Six Hundred Atlantic. Thanks for listening.

up down Acknowledgments